Back to the episode
MAKING YOU THINKNO. 07

Making You Think 7 · Rovelli's World, by Bas van Fraassen

Questions to ask yourself

No right answers · a few lines each

Think of an account you hold at work that you are sure is right. From where, exactly, is it right?

When two honest accounts of the same event differ, which one do you call the truth, and why that one?

What would count as a real contradiction between two of your records, rather than a difference?

Agile Insights · podcast.agile-insights.com.au/myt07-rovellis-world/Yours to keep. Nobody collects it.
MAKING YOU THINKNO. 07

Making You Think 7 · Rovelli's World, by Bas van Fraassen

Three accounts

10 minutes · alone · pen and paper

  1. Pick one recent event at work.
  2. Write it down from your position.
  3. Write it from the position of another person who was involved.
  4. Write it from someone who only ever saw the paperwork.
  5. Mark where the accounts merely differ, and where they truly conflict.

From my position

From someone else involved

From the paperwork only

PointDiffersConflicts

Most people find far more of the first than the second.

Agile Insights · podcast.agile-insights.com.au/myt07-rovellis-world/Yours to keep. Nobody collects it.
MAKING YOU THINKNO. 07

Making You Think 7 · Rovelli's World, by Bas van Fraassen

The comparison rule

5 minutes · alone · pen and paper

  1. Pick two records at work that ought to agree.
  2. Write down what, exactly, would count as a contradiction between them.
  3. Write down who would ever notice if one happened.

Record A and record B

A contradiction would be

Who would notice

If nobody would notice, you have found the place where the rule is not being checked.

Agile Insights · podcast.agile-insights.com.au/myt07-rovellis-world/Yours to keep. Nobody collects it.