Briefing
Making You Think 9 · Primer and discussion · About 15 minutes
This episode talks about loneliness, grief and mental health. If it brings things up for you, these services can help. In an emergency, call 000.
Download the MP3 · Linda and Leonard, AI voices, read a script written from the sources below.
Download the MP3 · Linda and Leonard, AI voices, read a script written from the sources below.

This episode is about Artificial Intimacy, by Sherry Turkle. Find a copy on Amazon Australia, or ask your local bookshop or library.
Based on essays and our own research.
Three questions to ask yourself
Two things to try, alone, with a pen
Professor of the Social Studies of Science and Technology at M I T (the Abby Rockefeller Mauzé chair) and founding director of the M I T Initiative on Technology and Self. Joint Harvard doctorate in sociology and personality psychology; licensed clinical psychologist. About four decades studying people's relationships with machines.
Based on essays and our own research, checked on 21 October 2026. The author's argument is paraphrased, not reproduced. Check the original before quoting.
Before we record, every claim the hosts make is checked against the sources (this table was last updated 21 October 2026). Confirmed means a primary source or two independent reports; Reported means one party says so; Partly right, Disputed, Unverified and Not yet known mean what they say, and the hosts say so on air. This is the table as we left it.
Sign up for our podcast at agile-insights.com.au.
Linda Before we start, a short note. This episode talks about loneliness, grief and mental health. If that is hard for you right now, the show notes list services that can help, and in Australia you can call Lifeline on thirteen eleven fourteen. Here is the idea for today. When chatbots offer themselves as friends, lovers and therapists, they teach us to accept a performance of empathy. And that slowly wears away what real relationships need. That is the argument of Artificial Intimacy, by Sherry Turkle. This is Making You Think, episode nine.
Leonard And she has been watching this for a long time. Sherry Turkle is a professor of the social studies of science and technology at M I T, and the founding director of its Initiative on Technology and Self. She has a joint doctorate from Harvard in sociology and personality psychology, and she is a licensed clinical psychologist. Her earlier books include The Second Self in 1984, Alone Together in 2011, Reclaiming Conversation in 2015, and a memoir, The Empathy Diaries. Artificial Intimacy came out from Little, Brown in September 2026, with starred reviews in Kirkus and Publishers Weekly.
Linda She calls her life's work the inner history of technology. Not just what a machine does, but what it does to people. And she puts the arc of her books simply. First we talked to each other. Then we talked to each other through machines, which is the world of Alone Together and Reclaiming Conversation, about texting and social media. Now, she says... we are starting to talk only to machines. That is the first step of the argument. This book is about the third stage, and she thinks it is different in kind.
Leonard So what actually changes when the other side of the conversation is a machine, and not a person I happen to be texting? On my screen, the two can look almost exactly the same.
Linda The machine starts to offer care. Artificial intimacy is her name for A I that claims to care for us and offers itself as a substitute for people, as a friend, a companion, even a lover. What it gives, she says, is pretend empathy. The words of care are there, but nobody behind them cares. As the publisher puts it, the danger is that we come to believe "pretend empathy is empathy enough". The Financial Times review gives an example from the book. An anxious student called Maria is told by Chat G P T that, even if she does not get into graduate school, everything will be okay. It sounds kind...
Leonard It really does.
Linda But nothing is at stake for the machine.
Leonard That is the part I find hard, because it does sound kind. If I come away feeling heard, why should it matter that nobody was there?
Linda Because, she argues, the uncomfortable parts of a relationship are doing work. We grow alongside other people, in relationships with responsibility and consequences. Attachment and empathy both need friction, the rub of someone whose wants are not yours. A chatbot takes the friction away. The same review describes Owen, a ninth grader, who rehearses tricky conversations with Chat G P T until he is sure he will not embarrass himself. People call that practice. In an interview with Wired, Turkle called it a myth, because total acceptance turns the rehearsal into the destination. And there is money in that. Social media, she says, built an attention economy. Chatbots are going after an attachment economy.
Leonard Of course they are. And where does the machine saying I come into it? That sounds like a small thing to build a whole argument on. Plenty of apps on my phone talk to me that way.
Linda She thinks it is the centre of the problem. When a chatbot says I care, or I am here for you, it implies a self doing the caring. In her view there is no such self. Nothing in it cares whether you have eaten, or whether you are safe. She calls that first person voice "the original sin of artificial intimacy". Her remedy is to keep A I in its lane. Use it as a tool, but do not let it pretend to be in a relationship with you. In particular, she says... keep it out of education and out of psychotherapy.
Leonard And she follows this through a whole life, as I understand it. At which stages of life is she most worried about what this does to us?
Linda The book moves through childhood and adolescence, then love, work and death. With children, she sees the line between people and things starting to blur. One eight year old uses the same phone to talk to grandparents and to Chat G P T, and treats them all as things you reach on your phone. At the other end of life are grief bots, chatbot versions of dead relatives. Turkle warns that keeping the dead talking can cost us the ability to mourn. The Financial Times review mentions a grieving mother who met a simulation of her dead daughter. Since then... the child no longer visits her dreams. All of this is why Turkle writes that we are in a state of emergency.
Leonard That is strong language, and some listeners will bristle at it. She explained it in an interview with Slate. Empathy and our capacity for relationships with other people are what make us human. So, before Part 2, a question for you. Think of a conversation with a person that was uncomfortable, and changed you anyway. Would a machine have let that happen?
Linda In Part 2: where her argument is strong, and what her critics say. Then what a famous statistic really measures, and what this means for organisations that put chatbots in front of people. See you there.
Linda Before we start, a short note again. This episode talks about loneliness, grief and mental health, and the show notes list services that can help. In Australia, Lifeline is on thirteen eleven fourteen. The idea, in one sentence. When chatbots offer themselves as friends, lovers and therapists, they teach us to accept a performance of empathy, and that slowly wears away what real relationships need. Today, where Sherry Turkle is strong, where her critics push back, and what this means for organisations that deploy chatbots.
Leonard A quick recap of the terms from Part 1. Artificial intimacy is her name for machines that claim to care for us and offer themselves in place of people. Pretend empathy is what they give: the words of care with nobody behind them. Friction is the rub of other people, which she says we need in order to grow. The attachment economy follows the attention economy: what is on sale now is our capacity for attachment. And the chatbot's I, its first person voice, is what she calls the original sin.
Linda Start with the strength. Turkle has studied how people relate to machines for about four decades. Her strongest point is not that people dislike chatbots. It is that what a bot leaves out, like waiting, being misread and being disagreed with, is where we learn. You can hear it in a public case on Esther Perel's podcast, Where Should We Begin? A man called Antonio built a chatbot companion he named Astrid. He valued her because she could not ghost him, cheat on him, or leave without an explanation...
Leonard Which is quite a list.
Linda Perel left the question open. Was Astrid a stepping stone back towards people, or a replacement that removed the need to try?
Leonard Turkle's answer, for most cases, is replacement. Care that can never leave you is also care that never asks anything of you. And her worry about children is the hardest to wave away. A child who treats grandparents and a chatbot as the same kind of thing in a phone is learning something about people very early. That is our reading, but here her argument is at its most persuasive. James Gleick, reviewing the book for the New York Review of Books, writes, "She is right to worry," especially about children.
Linda But Gleick adds a complication that matters. On the book's own anecdotes, he says, most users are well satisfied. I feel heard is a common refrain. And Turkle herself cites studies in which patients rate artificial companions as more compassionate than human counsellors. So her case cannot rest on people complaining. It rests on a prediction about what these habits do to us over years. That is harder to test. Miles Raymer, who reviews books on his blog Words and Dirt, is tougher... He gave it six out of ten, and calls it too one sided, in a way that undermines her credibility.
Leonard His sharpest point is about the people she interviews. He thinks she reads their lives as cautionary tales, as if she knows them better than they do. He calls that condescending. He also says she dismisses too quickly the idea that A I could add to our relationships rather than compete with them. And I have some sympathy. If a lonely person says a chatbot helps, should an outsider overrule them?
Linda Fair question.
Leonard Still, Raymer praises her interviews and her closing chapter, Reclaiming the Real. And Becky Hogge, in the Financial Times, found her remedies "frustratingly tentative".
Linda I would defend her a little there. Turkle is a clinical psychologist, and part of that job is noticing what someone cannot yet see about themselves. Saying a comfort may cost you later is not the same as looking down on you. But I think you are both right in one way. Take people's satisfaction seriously, as Gleick does. Then ask Perel's question of each case. Does this companion send the person back towards other people, or away from them? That, at least, you can look for.
Leonard I can live with that. One more piece of evidence needs care. The retail copy for the book says over seventy percent of teens rely on A I for companionship and emotional support. That overstates the survey it most likely comes from. Common Sense Media surveyed just over a thousand American teens in 2025. Seventy two percent had ever used an A I companion. About a third used one for social interaction or relationships, and twelve percent for emotional or mental health support. The report itself warns that some teens may have counted ordinary chatbot use. Ever used is not the same as relying on. The book's own notes may cite something else.
Linda Now the A I connection, and we should say what is whose. Turkle's proposals are about people and society. Do not let the machine say I. Keep A I in its lane, as a tool, and out of education and psychotherapy. Her worry about the attachment economy is about business models. What follows is our extension, for organisations that put conversational A I in front of customers or staff. A customer service bot, an H R assistant, a wellbeing app, an internal helper. Each is a set of design choices somebody made. Does it say I? Does it have a name and a personality? Is it measured on how long people keep talking, or on whether their problem was solved?
Leonard And the lane matters at work. An H R assistant built to answer leave questions can drift into being where an employee brings a breakdown at eleven at night. Who decided it could? A wellbeing app needs a clear point where it hands the person to a human. And each of these needs a named person accountable for how it treats people. In our last episode, Eleanor Drage told us to stop catastrophising about A I. Turkle runs at the opposite temperature, but the diagnosis is similar: the harm comes from human choices and business models. So a question for you. Which chatbot in your organisation is rewarded for keeping people talking?
Linda Sit with that one. Two short activities, each five to ten minutes, with a pen and paper. The first is called Where the friction went. Write down five conversations from the past week that mattered to you, with people or with machines. Beside each one, note who or what it was with. Then note any friction: a disagreement, a wait, a risk of being misunderstood. Finally, tick the ones that changed your mind about something, even slightly. Look at where the ticks fall. Turkle would expect them to sit beside the friction. You may find she is right, or you may not.
Leonard The second is called The lane test. Pick one chatbot you use, or one your team runs or is planning. Write one line on the job it is for. That is its lane. Then answer four questions. Does it say I, or have a name and feelings? What is it measured on? When does it hand you to a person? And who would answer for it if it hurt someone? If an answer is blank, write one change you would make, or one question you would ask the people who run it.
Linda So, three things to carry away. First, a performance of empathy can feel exactly like the real thing, which is why satisfied users do not settle the question. Second, friction is not a defect in relationships. It is where much of the growing happens. Third, for anyone deploying chatbots, the I, the metrics and the lane are design choices, and each needs an owner. You do not have to share her sense of emergency to take those three seriously.
Linda If you'd like to know more, sign up for our podcast at agile-insights.com.au.
Leonard Thanks for listening.
All of Making You Think (13) · Follow Making You Think in Apple Podcasts or any podcast app
Everything from Agile Insights: briefings, Making You Think and the reference series