Agile InsightsBriefing
Black and white photograph of a dark workbench: an upright hardback with a yellow ribbon and reading glasses, a wooden board game with one pawn halfway along the track labelled Visible progress, and a tally counter casting a long shadow labelled The shadow side. Title: The Game Changer.

Making You Think 12 · Primer and discussion · About 16 minutes

The Game Changer, by Jason Fox

When people seem unmotivated, design the work the way a good game is designed, with progress you can see.

#leadership#people

Part 1: Primer · About 7 minutes

Download the MP3 · Linda and Leonard, AI voices, read a script written from the sources below.

Part 2: Discussion · About 8 minutes

Download the MP3 · Linda and Leonard, AI voices, read a script written from the sources below.

Cover of The Game Changer

This episode is about The Game Changer, by Jason Fox. Find a copy on Amazon Australia, or ask your local bookshop or library.

Based on essays and our own research.

In this episode

01A third way to motivateInstead of changing attitudes, which takes effort, or paying incentives, which takes money, Fox's publisher says the book is about designing the work itself to be inherently motivating.
02Goals, rules and feedbackAs Fox defines it, a game is the interplay of goals, rules and feedback; most work has all three, usually badly designed. His line: it's not you, it's it.
03Progress is what mattersAmabile and Kramer's diary study of 238 people in seven companies found progress in meaningful work lifted the day most, so make progress visible and feedback fast.
04Every score casts a shadowFox warns every motivational element has a shadow side; critics add consent, a gamified classroom that lowered motivation, rewards that crowd out interest, and Goodhart's law.
05What to doLook at the design of the work before blaming people, make progress visible, test any score for its shadow, ask for consent, and measure A I progress, not A I use.

Your turn

Three questions to ask yourself

Think back over the last week. When did you feel you had made real progress on something that mattered, and could anyone else see it?
Which number at work do you chase that has stopped measuring what it was meant to measure?
If your organisation put everyone's A I use on a leaderboard, what would you do to climb it, and how much of that would be useful work?

Two things to try, alone, with a pen

10 minutesMap the gameBreak one piece of work into its goals, rules and feedback, and find the part that is out of whack.
5–10 minutesFind the shadowTake one measure or reward you work under and write down what it encourages that nobody intended.
Open the activity sheets (print or save as PDF)

About Jason Fox

Dr Jason Fox is a Melbourne-based author, speaker and leadership adviser. By his publisher's account he completed a PhD in motivation science young and lectured at three universities before leaving academia to work with business leaders on motivation and game design. His second book, How to Lead a Quest (Wiley, 2016), turned to leading through uncertainty. He now describes himself as a complexity practitioner, and says on his own site that his thinking has moved on since this book.

Other writing (3)
The Game Changer (2014) · Wiley (Australia)
the subject of this episode
How to Lead a Quest (2016) · Wiley (Australia)
leading pioneering work beyond default thinking and the delusion of progress; Making You Think 13
Books, on the author's own site (2026) · Jason Fox
his books and the small independent magazine The Cleverness Biannual, with his own note on how his thinking has changed
Sources and links (18)
Based on essays and our own research · The book on Amazon Australia
Where this episode comes from.
Wiley Australia, publisher page for the book · wiley.com
Wiley, look-inside excerpt: contents, introduction and chapter 1 · media.wiley.com
Jason Fox, Books (author's site) · foxwizard.com
his note that his thinking has moved on since this book
Fox, "Game on: 7 keys to increased productivity", Mortgage Professional Australia, 14 Apr 2014 · mpamag.com
"Is gamification over-hyped?", HC Online, 10 Apr 2014 · hcamag.com
Fox on why to be sceptical of gamification
HBR, "Breakthrough Ideas for 2010" (the progress principle) · hbr.org
Amabile and Kramer, "The Power of Small Wins", HBR, May 2011 · hbr.org
Harvard Library, on the goals study that was never found · ask.library.harvard.edu
Bogost, "Gamification is Bullshit", 2011 · bogost.com
the critic's case
Bogost, "Persuasive Games: Exploitationware", Gamasutra, 3 May 2011 · gamedeveloper.com
Mollick and Rothbard, "Mandatory Fun: Consent, Gamification and the Impact of Games at Work" · ssrn.com
Hanus and Fox, "Assessing the effects of gamification in the classroom", Computers and Education, 2015 · doi.org
Deci, Koestner and Ryan, meta-analysis of rewards and intrinsic motivation, Psychological Bulletin, 1999 · doi.org
Cameron and Pierce, "Reinforcement, reward, and intrinsic motivation", Review of Educational Research, 1994 · doi.org
Fortune, on Amazon staff gaming an A I usage leaderboard, 12 May 2026 · fortune.com
HRD Australia, "Amazon workers are gaming the AI leaderboard", 13 May 2026 · hcamag.com
Digital Commerce 360, on the Shopify chief executive's A I memo, 8 Apr 2025 · digitalcommerce360.com

Based on essays and our own research, checked on 26 October 2026. The publisher's copy, its look-inside excerpt (introduction and chapter 1), the author's site and his 2014 articles were read in full; the later chapters, the Mollick and Rothbard paper and the Hanus and Fox paper were not, and rest on reviews and published summaries. The author's argument is paraphrased, not reproduced. Check the original before quoting.

Our fact check · 45 claims: 33 confirmed, 6 reported, 1 disputed, 1 unverified, 2 not yet known

Before we record, every claim the hosts make is checked against the sources (this table was last updated 26 October 2026). Confirmed means a primary source or two independent reports; Reported means one party says so; Partly right, Disputed, Unverified and Not yet known mean what they say, and the hosts say so on air. This is the table as we left it.

The author

  1. ConfirmedDr Jason Fox, author; lives in Melbourne, AustraliaWiley author bio (2014); drjasonfox.com About (2026)
  2. ConfirmedBorn 1983National Library of Australia CiP data on the imprint page ("Fox, Jason, 1983- author"); Imprint; Do not say his age on air; not needed
  3. ConfirmedHolds a PhD; publisher: "levelling up with a PhD in record time"Wiley bio; excerpt; That he has one
  4. UnverifiedPhD institution (University of Melbourne? Murdoch?) and thesis topicOne search snippet (attributed to an HRM Online page that would not load) says Murdoch University, self-efficacy and goal attainment, completed 2010; No thesis record found (Trove, Murdoch portal, Minerva searched via web search). 2010 sits awkwardly with "by 25" and a 1983 birth year. Say only "a PhD in motivation science" on air. University of Melbourne: no evidence found
  5. ReportedTaught at three universities: his site says "living systems"; a 2022 conference bio says "systems and behaviour"Drjasonfox.com; SRA International 2022 keynote page (search result); His site says he taught complexity science, living systems and eco-philosophy
  6. ConfirmedFormer "young researcher in motivation science and goal setting" who told students the Yale goals storyExcerpt, ch. 1, p. 4; His own account; Useful colour: he admits spreading the myth himself
  7. ConfirmedNow calls himself a "wizard-philosopher, complexity practitioner and leadership advisor"; keynote speaker and adviser to large companies (Microsoft, Toyota, KPMG and others listed)Drjasonfox.com About; (self-description); client list Reported; 2014 bio named PepsiCo, Gartner, Toyota
  8. Not yet knownCompanyBusiness enquiries go via drjasonfox.com (partner Kim); site brand "foxwizard"; No company name confirmed; do not name one
  9. ConfirmedSays his thinking has "evolved quite significantly" since The Game Changer and he is "somewhat reluctant to promote it"Foxwizard.com/books (Oct 2026); Important for fairness: say on air that the author has moved on (his later work is about complexity and leading through uncertainty)
  1. ConfirmedMain idea: a third way: design the work itself to be inherently motivating, instead of changing attitudes (effort) or paying incentives (money)Wiley description; sample sheet; Idealog 2014; Carries the main idea; the one publisher quote: "designing the work itself to be inherently motivating"
  2. ConfirmedGames are goals, rules and feedback; good games goal-driven, challenge-intense, feedback-rich, geared towards progressExcerpt p. xv; MPA 2014; Elite Agent; Carries the main idea
  3. ConfirmedFox lines these up with intrinsic motivation, which he calls purpose, mastery and autonomyExcerpt p. xv; Pink's triad; SDT's is competence, autonomy, relatedness (Ryan and Deci 2000)
  4. Confirmed"It's not you. It's it." Lack of motivation is a design problem, not a character flawExcerpt p. xv; The one book quotation (5 words)
  5. ConfirmedThree principles: complex system, outside in; change is constant, process over distant goals; progress is the only thing that mattersExcerpt p. xx; Carries the main idea
  6. ConfirmedProgress in meaningful work is the strongest daily motivator (238 people, 7 companies, ~12,000 diary entries)Amabile and Kramer (HBR 2010, 2011; GovExec 2015 summary); Numbers via summaries; HBR list read; Carries step 3
  7. ConfirmedHBR named the progress principle its no. 1 breakthrough idea for 2010HBR list, Jan 2010; Fox's MPA claim checks out
  8. ReportedManagers ranked supporting progress last as a motivatorGovExec 2015; secondary summaries (669 managers); Use without the number, or "in a survey of several hundred managers"
  9. ConfirmedMake progress visible; shorten the gap between effort and feedbackMPA 2014 (Fox); Attributed to his 2014 article
  10. ConfirmedEvery motivational element has a shadow side; more quantitative, more shadowExcerpt pp. 18–19
  11. ReportedTumblr's "tumblarity" score (2009) flooded the site with posts and was removed within a year; eBay's seller score worksExcerpt pp. 17–18, quoting Deterding; As told in the book; Original Tumblr dates not independently checked; say "as Fox tells it"
  12. ConfirmedCulture cannot be tackled directly; behaviour, then culture, through artefacts and rituals (ch. 8)Excerpt p. xix; Signpost; Chapter 8 not read; not yet checked against the book
  13. ConfirmedThe Yale goals study never took placeExcerpt p. 4 (Wiseman); Harvard Library FAQ; Book's date (2007) and spelling (Tabuk) for the Fast Company piece are off: Partly right; not said on air
  14. ConfirmedFox once told the Yale story to his own studentsExcerpt p. 4; Good, humanising
  15. DisputedEinstein: play is the highest form of researchExcerpt; Quote Investigator 2014; Do not repeat as Einstein
  16. ConfirmedFox: be "incredibly sceptical" of gamification; good cases are sound motivation designHCA, 10 Apr 2014; Quote under 15 words
  17. ConfirmedFox: the answer is not turning work into a gameElite Agent interview; Paraphrase; Undated
  18. ConfirmedFox's thinking has evolved since; reluctant to promote the bookFoxwizard.com/books, 2026; Say on air, briefly
  19. ReportedFox holds a PhD in motivation science, by 25; lectured at three universitiesWiley sample sheet; TEDx 2013; Say "a PhD in motivation science" only
  20. ConfirmedSecond book How to Lead a Quest, Wiley, Jan 2016Wiley
  21. ConfirmedDeci, Koestner and Ryan 1999: 128 studies; d = -0.40, -0.36, -0.28Abstract (Europe PMC); Numbers optional on air
  22. ConfirmedCameron and Pierce 1994: 96 studies; overall no decreaseAbstract (OpenAlex)
  23. ConfirmedLepper, Greene and Nisbett 1973: expected award reduced later interestAbstract
  24. ConfirmedDay-care fine increased late pick-upsGneezy and Rustichini 2000, abstract; Ours, not the book's
  25. ConfirmedGamification defined as game design elements in non-game contextsDeterding et al. 2011
  26. ConfirmedGamification's effects depend greatly on context and usersHamari et al. 2014, abstract
  27. ConfirmedBogost: gamification is marketing; "exploitationware"Bogost 2011 (both pieces); On air say "exploitationware"
  28. ConfirmedMollick and Rothbard: consent decides whether a work game helps or harmsWharton Magazine 2016; commentary; SSRN listing; Secondary; Paper not read; no numbers
  29. ConfirmedHanus and (Jesse) Fox 2015: gamified course, lower motivation, satisfaction and exam scoresSecondary accounts; Crossref metadata; Secondary; No relation to Jason Fox
  30. ConfirmedGoodhart 1975 (RBA conference, Sydney); Strathern 1997 paraphraseSearch summaries; Crossref (Strathern); Strathern citation); Reported (Goodhart wording
  31. ReportedAmazon staff gamed an AI token leaderboard ("tokenmaxxing"), reported by the FT, May 2026Fortune 12 May 2026; HRD Australia 13 May 2026; FT original not read
  32. ReportedMeta's "Claudeonomics" leaderboard ranked ~85,000 staff by tokens; taken downFortune; HRD
  33. ConfirmedShopify CEO, Apr 2025: reflexive AI use a baseline expectation; part of performance reviewsDigital Commerce 360, 8 Apr 2025; Report of the memo; Quote under 15 words if used
  34. Book discusses AINone; Not applicable; Written 2013, published 2014; say so
  35. AI leaderboards as tumblarity; progress not usage; consent; GoodhartHosts' extension; Ours; Said so on air
  36. Not yet knownContent of chapters 2 to 9Not reached

Want to know more?

Sign up for our podcast at agile-insights.com.au.

Read the transcript · Part 1: Primer

Linda The idea for today is that when people at work seem unmotivated, the fix is rarely to change their attitudes or to pay them more, but to design the work itself the way a good game is designed, with progress you can see. That is the argument of The Game Changer, by the Australian writer Doctor Jason Fox. By the end of this part you will know what Fox means by a game, why progress sits at the centre of it, and why every motivational trick casts a shadow. This is Making You Think, episode twelve.

Leonard Last episode was game theory, so this is the other half of the word game. Jason Fox is based in Melbourne. By his publisher's account he completed a PhD in motivation science young, and lectured at three universities, before leaving academia to work with business leaders. The Game Changer came out from Wiley in Australia in 2014. His second book, How to Lead a Quest, followed in 2016, and that is our next episode. In fairness to him, on his own website today he says his thinking has moved on a long way since this book, and that he is "somewhat reluctant to promote it". So we are treating it as a strong idea from 2014, not as his last word.

Linda Step one is the two levers most of us were taught. The first is to change people's attitudes and beliefs, with pep talks and seminars. That takes a lot of effort. The second is to pay for performance, with bonuses and incentives. That takes a lot of money. Fox opens by clearing away some folklore. You may have heard of a Yale study where the few graduates who wrote down their goals later earned more than the rest combined...

Leonard I have heard that one.

Linda Fox points out that no such study has ever been found, and he admits he once told the story to his own students. Rewards do work, he says, but at a cost. People focus on the reward, look for shortcuts, and can lose creativity and the will to collaborate.

Leonard So if it is not attitudes and it is not money, what is left?

Linda Step two, and it is the heart of the book. Fox's third way, in his publisher's words, is "designing the work itself to be inherently motivating". His model is the game. A game, as Fox defines it, is the interplay of three things: goals, rules and feedback. A good game is driven by a goal, it is challenging, it is rich in feedback, and it is geared towards progress. Now look at any project at work. It has goals, rules and feedback too. They are just usually designed badly, or not designed at all. When one of the three is out of whack, motivation sags. His shortest line for this is "It's not you. It's it." The problem is the design, not a flaw in your character.

Leonard That explains my inbox. In a 2014 article, Fox gave the example of someone who clears seventy four emails instead of working on the important project. It is not laziness. Clearing the inbox simply gives a clearer sense of progress than the big project does. The emails have a goal, a rule and instant feedback. The project has a goal three months away and no feedback until the end. Fox also lines his game up with what drives people from the inside. He uses Daniel Pink's three words from the book Drive: purpose, mastery and autonomy. Self determination theory, the research Pink built on, has a slightly different list: competence, autonomy and relatedness, which means feeling connected to other people.

Linda Mine too. Step three is the principle Fox puts above all the others. Progress is the only thing that matters. It rests on research by Teresa Amabile of Harvard Business School and Steven Kramer. They had two hundred and thirty eight people, in seven companies, keep daily diaries, nearly twelve thousand entries in all. Of everything that lifted people's working day, the most powerful was making progress in meaningful work, even a small step. The Harvard Business Review named it the top breakthrough idea of 2010. In a separate survey the researchers reported, managers ranked supporting progress last among the things that motivate people. So Fox's practical advice is simple. Make progress visible, and shorten the gap between effort and feedback.

Leonard I like that. Think of a team wall covered in task cards, or a short daily stand up where everyone says what moved. Neither of those is a reward. Both of them make progress visible. Before we go on, a question for you. Think back over the last week. When did you feel you had made real progress on something that mattered, and could anyone else see it?

Linda Step four is the warning, and Fox gives it himself. Every motivational element has what he calls a shadow side. A bonus may buy focus at the cost of creativity. An annual award may lift a few people and leave the rest resentful. The more a thing is counted, he says, the more likely it is to cast a shadow. His example, as he tells it, is the blogging site Tumblr. Around 2009 it showed users a popularity score called tumblarity. People chased the score, the site filled up with sheer volume, and the score was gone within a year...

Leonard Of course it was.

Linda The seller ratings on eBay, by contrast, work, because they line up with what buyers and sellers actually want.

Leonard So you cannot just bolt a scoreboard onto a team and call the job done. Fox's answer is to treat every change as an experiment. Try one, play test it, watch what it does to progress, and then keep it or drop it. He calls himself a progressionist rather than a perfectionist. He also makes a bigger claim about culture. You cannot change a culture directly. Culture follows behaviour, and behaviour follows the design of the work, through the small artefacts and rituals a team lives with. Last episode we said to look at the game before blaming the players. Fox says the same about motivation. Before you blame the people, look at the goals, the rules and the feedback.

Linda In Part 2: where the idea is strong, the critics who think gamification is a con, a study of a gamified classroom, and what happened in 2026 when companies put A I use on a leaderboard. See you there.

Read the transcript · Part 2: Discussion

Linda The idea again, in one sentence: when people seem unmotivated, look first at the design of the work, its goals, rules and feedback, and make progress visible, before you try to change their attitudes or pay them more. A quick recap from Part 1. For Jason Fox, a game is the interplay of goals, rules and feedback. Progress, as he puts it, is the only thing that matters. And every motivational element has a shadow side, an effect nobody intended. Today: the strengths, the critics, what this has to do with A I, and two activities.

Leonard Strength first. The reframe moves the question from fixing people to fixing the work, and that is a kinder question and usually a more useful one. A manager cannot install motivation in someone's head. A manager can change a deadline, remove an approval step, or show a team what its effort moved. The second strength is evidence. Progress is the part of his argument with the firmest research behind it, those twelve thousand diary entries. The third is his own scepticism. In a 2014 interview with H C Online, Fox said we should be "incredibly sceptical" of gamification. When it works, he said, it is really just sound motivation design. He is not selling points and badges.

Linda Now the critics, and the first is blunt. In 2011 the game designer and scholar Ian Bogost called gamification a marketing term invented by consultants. He argued that it takes the easy, incidental parts of games, the points and levels and leaderboards, and mistakes them for the whole thing. He suggested a different name for it: exploitationware. Fox would say he agrees, and that he is not adding points. But a book called The Game Changer, sold to managers, sits close to what Bogost attacked. The test for any listener is whether a change makes the work itself better, or only wraps a score around it.

Leonard Strong word.

Linda It is.

Leonard The second objection is consent. Ethan Mollick and Nancy Rothbard at the Wharton School studied a sales team at a technology company that was given a basketball themed game, with points and a leaderboard. People who agreed to the game felt more positive about their work. People who had not agreed felt worse. Same game, opposite effect. The third is a classroom study from 2015 by Michael Hanus and Jesse Fox at Ohio State University, no relation to Jason. A course with compulsory badges and a leaderboard ended with lower motivation, lower satisfaction and lower final exam scores than an identical course without them.

Linda The fourth objection is older than any of this. Rewards can crowd out the motivation they are meant to build. A 1999 review by Edward Deci, Richard Koestner and Richard Ryan pooled one hundred and twenty eight experiments...

Leonard That many?

Linda That many. It found that rewards for doing, finishing or performing a task reduced people's own interest in it, while positive feedback raised it. Other researchers, Judy Cameron and David Pierce, argued that the harm is narrower than often claimed. And there is the economist Charles Goodhart, speaking in Sydney in 1975. In the familiar paraphrase, when a measure becomes a target, it stops being a good measure. Fox's Tumblr story is Goodhart's law in miniature.

Leonard I want to push on something, though. Isn't designing the game just a nicer word for manipulation? If I arrange your goals, your rules and your feedback so that you work harder, I am steering you, whether you can see it or not. A bonus at least announces itself. A well designed game might not.

Linda That is a fair worry, and Fox raises it himself. He opens the book with a seminar that moves a room full of people to buy an expensive program, and he admits he both admires and loathes it. His conclusion is that all motivation is a kind of manipulation, and that what matters is the intent. I don't think intent is enough. The Mollick study suggests a better test. Can the people see the rules, and did they agree to play? Design that is visible and agreed to is not manipulation. It is just a well run team. So a question for you. Which number at work do you chase that has stopped measuring what it was meant to measure?

Leonard That I can live with. Visible, and agreed. Now A I, and first a plain statement. Fox wrote this book in 2013, before generative A I, and it does not discuss it. What follows is our extension, not his. In May 2026 the Financial Times reported, as relayed by Fortune, that some Amazon staff were running an internal A I tool on trivial tasks to climb a leaderboard of usage. Fortune also reported that Meta had a leaderboard ranking staff by how much A I they used, and that it was taken down. And in April 2025, Shopify's chief executive wrote that using A I was now a baseline expectation, and would be part of performance reviews.

Linda This is tumblarity all over again. Make a number the target, and people will raise the number. Usage is the easiest thing to count about A I, and the thing least connected to value. Fox's lens asks a better question. What progress is the A I meant to produce, and can the people using it see that progress? The Mollick study adds a second question. Did people agree to the game? And Goodhart predicts the rest. So a question for you. If your organisation put everyone's A I use on a leaderboard, what would you do to climb it, and how much of that would be useful work?

Leonard Two short activities, each five to ten minutes, with a pen and paper. The first is called Map the game. Pick one piece of your work that drags. Draw three columns: goals, rules and feedback. In each column, write what it actually is today, not what it should be. Circle the one that is out of whack: a goal nobody believes, a rule that adds friction, or feedback that comes too late. Then write one change you could try for the next two weeks. Fox's test for any change is simple. Is it making progress happen?

Linda The second is called Find the shadow. Pick one measure, reward or league table you work under, or one you run. Write what it was meant to encourage. Then write how someone could hit it without doing the real work, and what it might cost: creativity, collaboration or trust. Tick whether the people it measures agreed to it. Finally, write one change. Measure progress instead, or ask first. Keep Goodhart in mind as you do it. When a measure becomes a target, it stops being a good measure.

Leonard So what to carry away. First, when motivation sags, look at the design of the work, its goals, rules and feedback, before you blame the people or reach for a bonus. Second, make progress visible, and shorten the gap between effort and feedback, because that part has the strongest evidence. Third, every score casts a shadow, so test it, ask for consent, and watch what people do to hit it. Fox himself has moved on from this book, but those three habits travel well, especially now that organisations are starting to count how much A I their people use.

Linda If you'd like to know more, sign up for our podcast at agile-insights.com.au.

Leonard Thanks for listening.

More on #leadership

Episode 34 · Primer and discussionWhen the test stops telling you anything: hunger beats tenureMaking You Think 5 · Primer and discussionSeeing Systems, by Barry OshryEpisode 6 · DiscussionThe Five Dysfunctions of a Team: a checklist for AI adoption, not a lawEpisode 38 · Primer and discussionBudgeted for seats, billed for workEpisode 23 · Primer and discussionWhat FDE means at OpenAI: skills, not custom code.Episode 21 · DiscussionTrust cannot be rushed: how much authority will you give AI?

Every episode tagged #leadership

All of Making You Think (13) · Follow Making You Think in Apple Podcasts or any podcast app

Everything from Agile Insights: briefings, Making You Think and the reference series